Weird Crime Comedy: 12 Entertaining True Crime Comedy Podcasts

True crime podcasts have become increasingly popular in recent years, with listeners drawn to the gripping stories and the hosts’ insights. There are now a wide variety of true crime podcasts available, each with its own unique approach.

1. Not Another True Crime Podcast

Not Another True Crime Podcast

Hosted by Sara Levine and Danny Murphy, this podcast is a crowd favorite for a reason. It is a humorous take on true crime, with all the scary and creepy details you might think and hope for. Each episode focuses on a different case, and the hosts do a deep dive into the facts, interviewing experts and witnesses along the way. They also provide their own commentary and theories, which often leads to fun and interesting debates between hosts.

In addition to covering true crime cases, Not Another True Crime Podcast also features episodes on other topics related to crime, such as cults, conspiracy theories, and serial killers. The hosts also interview authors, journalists, and other experts on these topics.

2. And That’s Why We Drink

True Crime Comedy Podcasts

With best friends Em Schulz and Christine Schiefer at realms, this is a wildly popular podcast that blends true crime and paranormal stories with a delightful mix of humor and crime, gruesome, gruesome crime. “And That’s Why We Drink is a true crime and paranormal podcast.

Each episode follows a unique format where Em shares a true crime story while Christine delves into a paranormal or supernatural encounter. Their witty banter and genuine chats makes you wanna stay along for each episode, making listeners feel like they’re part of a conversation.

3. Those Conspiracy Guys

True Crime Comedy Podcast: Those Conspiracy Guys

Hosted by comedians Ben Kissel, Henry Zebrowski, and Marcus Parks, “Those Conspiracy Guys” is a podcast that explores all sorts of conspiracy theories. The hosts are not afraid to poke fun at the more outlandish theories, but they also take the time to research and investigate the more credible ones.

4. Ye Olde Crime

True Crime Comedy Podcast: Ye Olde Crime

Ye Olde Crime is a true crime podcast hosted by sisters Lindsay Valenty and Madison Stangl. The podcast covers a wide range of cases, from the well-known to the obscure, with a focus on cases from the past. Lindsay and Madison are both passionate about history and true crime, and they bring their love of both subjects to the podcast. Want another reason to tune in? The hosts’ knowledge of history. Lindsay and Madison are both well-versed in history, and they bring their knowledge to bear on the cases they cover. This makes the podcast more informative and educational, as well as entertaining.

5. All Killa No Filla

All Killa No FillaHosted by comedians Rachel Fairburn and Kiri Pritchard-McLean, this show brings a fresh and hilarious twist to the dark world of serial killers.

In each episode, Rachel and Kiri dive deep into the chilling stories of infamous serial killers, blending humor and wit to create a unique and engaging experience. You’ll find yourself laughing along with their banter, while also getting a dose of spine-chilling facts about some of the most notorious criminals in history.

6. My Favorite Murder

My Favorite MurderWith Karen Kilgariff and Georgia Hardstark at mics, “My Favorite Murder” is a true crime podcast with a fresh and engaging perspective to the true crime genre.
In each episode, Karen and Georgia share their favorite murder cases and other intriguing tales from the world of crime. But don’t worry, it’s not all doom and gloom – their witty banter and comedic approach add a unique and light-hearted touch to the stories.

With millions and millions of downloads, it has spawned a live tour, a book, and a merchandise line, this podcast that has become a cultural phenomenon. Forgot to mention, their fanbase is known as the “Murderinos.”

7. Last Podcast on the Left

Last Podcast on the Left

Paying a nod to the 1972 horror movie “The Last House on the Left”, the dynamic trio, Ben Kissel, Marcus Parks, and Henry Zebrowski managed to create a podcast that blends comedy, research, and storytelling to perfection. But don’t let the laughs fool you – “Last Podcast on the Left” is meticulously researched, and the hosts take the stories seriously while also embracing their eccentric and offbeat style. You’ll hear all about true crime, conspiracy theory, and of course, the paranormal.

8. True Crime Obsessed

True Crime ObsessedHosted by the fabulous duo, Patrick Hinds and Gillian Pensavalle, “True Crime Obsessed” is a podcast that discusses true crime cases that have been covered in other podcasts. So, yeah, a recap of cases that caused quite a stir at the time. This isn’t your typical true crime podcast – it’s like having a movie night with your funniest friends as you dissect real-life crime stories together. With their infectious enthusiasm and honest reactions, they create an inviting and inclusive community of true crime enthusiasts known as “The TCO Family. “True Crime Obsessed has a ton of downloads, and it has been praised for its humor, its research, and its willingness to challenge the status quo.

9. Wine & Crime

Wine & Crime

You’ll tune in to three hilarious and witty friends – Lucy Fitzgerald, Kenyon Laing and Amanda Jacobson – this show is a perfect blend of true crime storytelling and wine-fueled fun.

The hosts discuss cases in a serious way, but they also like to have fun and drink wine along the way. In each episode, the hosts pick a crime-related theme and pair it with a delicious wine. “Wine & Crime” is like having a true crime book club with your besties #WinningPodcastSoFar

10. Crime in Sports

Crime in SportsLadies and gents, the dark side of sports. The hosts discuss cases involving athletes who have committed crimes, both on and off the field. Created by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman, this show uncovers the shocking and often bizarre criminal histories of athletes.

They will take you on a rollercoaster ride through the lives of famous athletes who have found themselves on the wrong side of the law, willingly or not. “Crime in Sports” isn’t just about the crimes; it’s about the fascinating and often tumultuous lives of athletes before, during, and after their careers. The hosts have a knack for balancing humor with respect for the seriousness of the cases they cover.

11. Small Town Murder

Small Town Murder

Hosted by James Pietragallo and Jimmie Whisman (the same dynamic duo from “Crime in Sports”), this show uncovers the shocking and lesser-known true crime stories from small, often overlooked, communities. In each episode, James and Jimmie take you on a thrilling journey through the crime-ridden streets of small towns, bringing to light intriguing cases and bizarre mysteries. “Small Town Murder” is not your typical true crime podcast – it’s like having a darkly humorous tour guide taking you through the seedy underbelly of America’s hidden corners.

12. Women Who Kill with Kai Choyce

Women Who Kill with Kai Choyce

In each episode, Kai takes you on a gripping journey through the lives and crimes of female killers, shining a spotlight on the often overlooked and compelling stories of women everywhere. “Women Who Kill” isn’t just about the crimes – it’s about understanding the complex motivations and circumstances that led these women down a path of violence. Kai’s insightful commentary and empathy for the subjects create a thought-provoking and informative listening experience. Mind you, it’s a lot to take in at times.

Recommended reading next: 8 of the weirdest murders you’ll ever hear about

Is it okay to find humor in murder?

Whether or not it is okay to find humor in murder is a personal decision. Some people find that humor can help them to cope with difficult or disturbing information, while others find it to be disrespectful or insensitive. Ultimately, it is up to each individual to decide whether or not they are comfortable listening to funny murder podcasts.

Why are funny murder podcasts popular?

There are a few reasons why funny murder podcasts are popular. First, humor can be a coping mechanism for some people, and it can help them to process difficult or disturbing information. Second, humor can make true crime stories more accessible to a wider audience. Third, funny murder podcasts can be a way to learn about the dark side of human nature in a more lighthearted way.

What are some tips for listening to funny murder podcasts responsibly?

If you are considering listening to a funny murder podcast, here are a few tips for doing so responsibly:

Be aware of your own triggers. If you are sensitive to certain topics, such as violence or abuse, then you may want to avoid listening to podcasts that deal with those topics.

Take breaks. If you find yourself feeling overwhelmed or disturbed by the content of a podcast, then take a break and come back to it later.

Talk to someone. If you are feeling uncomfortable or conflicted about listening to a funny murder podcast, then talk to someone about it. A therapist or counselor can help you to process your emotions and to develop healthy coping mechanisms.

True crime podcasts can be a great way to learn about some of the most shocking and disturbing crimes that have ever been committed. They can also be a source of entertainment, as many hosts have a knack for making even the most gruesome stories funny. If you are a fan of true crime, or if you are just looking for a new podcast to listen to, then be sure to check out some of the podcasts that we have mentioned in this article. You won’t be disappointed.

Related Post

Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Would love your thoughts, please comment.x